Two General Effect Judges, One Sheet: Pacific Crest Scored Better From One Chair in 12 of 15 Shows
GE1 and GE2 now judge the same thing. Most corps get the same read from both. A few get a consistent lean.
Pacific Crest marched 15 scored shows in 2026. In 12 of them, the General Effect 1 judge gave the corps a higher number than the General Effect 2 judge, by 0.23 on average. Only twice did it go the other way.
That matters because the two General Effect captions now work from the same sheet. Since DCI moved away from separate music and visual effect captions, GE1 and GE2 are two independent reads of the same thing: how well the show works. A corps should, in principle, score about the same from both.
Most corps do
For most of the field the two chairs land close and split their leans fairly evenly. Madison Scouts were higher from GE1 in 8 shows and from GE2 in 7. Music City split 8 and 9.
A few corps lean consistently the other way. Seattle Cascades scored higher from GE2 in 14 of 18 shows, Troopers in 14 of 19, and Genesis in 11 of 16, by 0.27 on average.
Two chairs, one sheet, and for a handful of corps, a steady difference.
What it might mean, and what it might not
General Effect judges come from different backgrounds. Many GE1 judges have spent their careers in visual and design, and many GE2 judges in music. A show whose strengths are visual could read better from one chair and a show built on its music from the other, even on a shared sheet.
It might also be people, not chairs. The same few judges sit in these chairs across a season, and a lean could belong to an individual rather than a seat. This piece does not check who sat where on each night, and it names no one.
The leans are a few tenths, and they come out in the GE total either way, because both captions count. They matter most to a corps near a cut line, where a tenth decides who keeps marching.