DCI FORGE

DCI Analysis · Scores · Stories

The Analysis Desk

DCI Doubles Three Judging Chairs at Championships. One Judge Alone Would Have Moved the 2023 Silver

Two judges in the same caption, fifteen Championship nights, five years. The title never moves. The places just behind it do.

In 2023, Carolina Crown finished 0.075 behind Bluecoats for the silver medal. In General Effect 1 that night, one judge had Crown two tenths ahead of Bluecoats. The other judge in the same caption had Bluecoats half a point ahead of Crown. The recap averages the two, and Bluecoats kept second.

A split like that is visible one week a year. At Prelims, Semifinals and Finals, DCI seats two judges in General Effect 1, General Effect 2 and Music Analysis and prints both numbers. The recaps from 2022 through 2026 cover fifteen of those nights, and they answer two questions: how often do two judges in the same chair disagree, and what would have changed with only one of them in the box?

No judge is named here. The question is about the chair, not the person in it.

Two judges, same caption, same night

Take any two corps on a given night and ask each judge in a doubled caption which one was better. Across the fifteen nights that is 4,500 pairings per caption. The two General Effect 1 judges put a pair in opposite order 162 times, 3.6 percent. General Effect 2: 172 times, 3.8 percent. Music Analysis: 170 times, 3.8 percent.

For scale, two different captions judged by two different people disagree about as often. Visual Proficiency and Visual Analysis split on 4.9 percent of pairs. Brass and Music Analysis split on 4.2 percent. Only Percussion stands apart: it disagrees with Brass on 8.5 percent.

A second judge on the same caption is roughly as different as a second caption.

In points, the two judges in a doubled caption sat 0.29 apart on the average corps, on a 20-point caption. On 16 to 21 percent of corps they were half a point or more apart. That is the noise a single chair carries every other night of the summer, measured on the only nights it can be.

What one judge would have done

Averaging two judges is DCI's design, and the results stand as scored. But the recaps let you ask what the result would have been with one judge in each doubled chair. There are two judges in each of three captions, so eight possible one-judge panels per night.

The title does not move. In all five years, every one of the eight panels crowns the same Finals winner. 2024, 2025 and 2026 Finals do not change a single podium place under any of them.

The places behind the title do move.

2023 Finals. Bluecoats took silver on 97.738, Carolina Crown bronze on 97.663. In General Effect 1, one judge had Crown 19.7 and Bluecoats 19.5. The other had Bluecoats 19.8 and Crown 19.3. Every panel built on the first of those judges, four of the eight, puts Crown second.

2022 Finals. The recap shows Bluecoats and Boston Crusaders on the same total, 97.325, and lists Bluecoats second. Four of the eight panels put Boston ahead.

2026 Semifinals. Blue Knights took the last Finals spot on 86.750. Pacific Crest was 13th on 86.663, 0.087 short. Two of the eight panels put Pacific Crest in, by 0.05 each time.

2022 Semifinals. Two panels send Crossmen to Finals from 13th, one at the expense of Colts and one at the expense of Troopers.

The Semifinals cut. At 2023 Prelims, one panel moves The Battalion into Semifinals in place of Jersey Surf. At 2024 Prelims, two panels move Columbians in for The Battalion.

The weights matter less than you'd think

There is another way to ask the same question. DCI weights its sheet 40 percent general effect and 60 percent performance. Bands of America runs the other way: 60 percent effect, 40 percent performance, by its own published philosophy.

Re-weight the 2026 season the BOA way and 13 of 1,496 head-to-head results flip, under one percent. No show changes its winner. But re-weight Championship week and two cut lines move: Pacific Crest into the 2026 Finals, and Columbians into the 2024 Semifinals.

Those are two of the same lines that move when you take away the second judge. Some results are decided with room to spare. A few are decided inside the noise, and whichever way you nudge the sheet, those are the ones that fall.

What it does and doesn't mean

It does not mean anyone was robbed. The two-judge average is the rule everyone marched under, and it exists for exactly this reason: one chair is noisy, two are less so.

It does mean a margin under about a tenth at Championships is a margin the sheet cannot really see. Pacific Crest's 0.087 in 2026 and the 0.075 between Bluecoats and Crown in 2023 sit inside the gap that two qualified people scoring the same caption routinely open between themselves.

And it raises a question for the rest of the summer. At a regular show, each of those captions has one judge, and the General Effect 1 and 2 judges now work from the same sheet. In 2026 those two chairs split on 4.6 percent of pairs across 49 shows. Every regular-season night carries the noise Championship week was built to dampen.

The case against

Fifteen nights is a real sample of pairs and a small sample of decisions. Six nights with a moved line in five years is a handful, and every one of them came from a margin already under a tenth.

The two judges in a doubled caption also sit in different places and may be watching for different things. Some of their disagreement may be two honest views of a show, not noise. The recap cannot tell those apart.

And a one-judge panel is a thought experiment. Nobody marched for one judge in August. What it measures is how close the line was, not who should have crossed it.

Sources

  1. 2026 DCI World Championship adjudication panels
  2. 2023 World Championship Finals recap (World Class)
  3. 2026 World Championship Semifinals recap (World Class)
  4. 2022 World Championship Semifinals recap (World Class)
  5. 2022 World Championship Finals recap (World Class)
  6. 2023 World Championship Prelims recap (World Class)
  7. 2024 World Championship Prelims recap (World Class)
  8. Bands of America adjudication system
← All Articles