DCI FORGE

DCI Analysis · Scores · Stories

The Analysis Desk

By Mid-July the DCI Field Is Already Sorted. August Mostly Confirms It

Four seasons of early-July standings against the Semifinals order: a 0.92 match, and only a handful of corps who really moved.

The usual line in August is that the season is still wide open. The record from 2022 through 2025 says it mostly is not.

Take each corps' standing across the shows it marched through July 15, measured by where it placed inside each night's field, and line that order up against the Semifinals order three and a half weeks later. The rank correlation is 0.94 in 2022, 0.94 in 2023, 0.86 in 2024 and 0.95 in 2025. A correlation of 1 would mean nothing moved at all.

Finals night changes even less

Semifinals to Finals is the shortest gap in the season, and the one with the most drama attached. In 2023, 2024 and 2026 the Finals order matched the Semifinals order exactly, top to bottom. In 2022 two corps traded 8th and 9th. In 2025 two pairs swapped, 8th and 9th, and 1st and 2nd.

That last swap is the only time in five years the lead changed overnight: Boston Crusaders were 2nd at Semifinals and won the 2025 title.

One lead change in five Finals nights. The drama is real, and it is rare.

Who actually moved

Most corps finished within a place of where July had them: 12 of 18 in 2022, 13 of 20 in 2023, 11 of 20 in 2024 and 12 of 21 in 2025. The exceptions are where the season happened.

In 2023, Bluecoats climbed from about 5th in early July to 2nd at Semifinals, while Blue Stars slid from about 6th to 11th. In 2024, Blue Stars went the other way, from about 15th to 8th, and Madison Scouts from about 18th to 12th. In 2025, Santa Clara Vanguard rose from about 6th to 3rd as Phantom Regiment dropped from about 3rd to 6th.

Settled, or slotted?

Numbers like these feed one of the oldest arguments in drum corps. Fans call it slotting: the belief that judges settle on an order early in the summer and then score to protect it, so a corps placed behind a rival in June can clean, rewrite and improve all season and still finish behind that rival in August.

A stable order is what slotting would look like. It is also what a simpler season would look like, one where the corps that start strong have the staff, the money and the rehearsal hours to stay strong. These standings can't tell those two apart. Doing that means looking under the total: whether caption ranks move more than overall ranks, whether a panel that saw a corps early keeps it where it first put it, and whether late gains shrink the further down the order a corps starts. That is a bigger piece, and we are building it. The 2024 Blue Stars, up about seven places in three and a half weeks, are the case any slotting theory has to explain.

What this measure can and can't see

Early-July fields are partial. Not every corps meets every other corps, so the July order here is built from where each corps placed inside each night's lineup, averaged across its shows. That is an estimate, and it is why the July places above carry an 'about'. Semifinals places are counted the same way, among the corps in both samples.

It also says nothing about quality. A corps that holds its place all summer may be improving as fast as everyone around it. What the record shows is the order, and by mid-July the order is mostly set.

Sources

  1. 2022 Semifinals recap
  2. 2023 Semifinals recap
  3. 2024 Semifinals recap
  4. 2025 Semifinals recap
  5. 2025 Finals recap
← All Articles